New Jersey Environmental Protection Agency
Jon Hurdle / StateImpact PA
Several government agencies have questioned the need for and significant aspects of the PennEast project, a new 118-mile natural-gas pipeline already facing wide opposition from residents of New Jersey and Pennsylvania. The proposed pipeline would bring Marcellus Shale gas from Northeast Pennsylvania, across the Delaware River, to supply New Jersey utilities.
The comments from state and federal agencies repeatedly decry a significant lack of information and unanswered questions raised by the draft environmental impact statement (EIS) issued by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) earlier this summer.
The response by the government agencies could trigger new delays in the $1.1 billion project, one of more than a dozen pipelines that have been proposed in Pennsylvania and New Jersey since cheap natural-gas supplies have been exploited in Pennsylvania and neighboring states. The new wells have driven down heating costs for consumers and manufacturing costs for businesses. Read more at NJ Spotlight.
In separate comments to FERC, the New Jersey Rate Counsel, an independent consumer advocate for ratepayers, said the project failed to demonstrate the need for a new pipeline to deliver gas to customers, saying the venture seems to be motivated more by profit than by demand.
“What we want to make sure though is that there really is a demonstration of need, ” New Jersey Rate Counsel director Stefanie Brand told StateImpact. “Because [the gas] would only be cheaper if it’s really needed. If we’re building [pipeline] capacity that we don’t need, then it would be more expensive.”
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s Region III office concluded that the project “results in significant adverse environmental impacts, ’’ including possibly mobilizing naturally occurring arsenic into groundwater.
Like other agencies, the EPA also said a significant amount of information is omitted from the draft EIS. To project opponents, those concerns raise doubts whether several key environmental permits could be issued for the project without answering ways to mitigate adverse impacts to forests, wetlands, and the 255 waterways it would cross.
Other agencies weighing in with negative comments on the proposal included the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and the National Park Service. Among other concerns, several agencies questioned why the draft EIS gave short shrift to the “no action’’ alternative.
Critics of the project were elated by the government’s response. “These agencies are clearly signaling that, as it stands right now, these projects would not be approved, ’’ said Tom Gilbert, campaign director for the New Jersey Conservation Foundation.
The comments from the New Jersey government entities were surprising in that the Christie administration has put a priority on expanding the energy infrastructure in New Jersey, incorporating the issue into its Energy Master Plan.
But Rate Counsel Director Stefanie Brand and her agency’s consultant were particularly opposed to the $1.1 billion project, saying the developer failed to demonstrate the project is needed and is unduly generous to PennEast and unfair to consumers.
“It doesn’t in our mind truly demonstrate that the pipeline is necessarily needed, ” said Brand. “And what we’re asking for FERC to do is look more closely and see if they’re giving up capacity on other pipelines to build this.”
Rate Counsel’s argument that the project is not needed to deliver gas to consumers echoes a recurring criticism from opponents who have long argued the region can meet gas demand even on the coldest days without the project.
But PennEast countered that the project is 90 percent subscribed, which speaks for itself, according to Pat Kornick, a spokesman for the company. As for the concerns raised by the agencies, Kornick said obtaining such input is an expectation of the regulatory process.
“As PennEast proceeds through the FERC process, PennEast will continue to provide FERC with all necessary information, ’’ Kornick said.
If the project moves forward, PennEast and its sponsors—including all four New Jersey gas utilities—will earn a 14 percent return on equity, well above the more traditional range of 8 percent.
“In this financial environment, the opportunity to receive a commission-regulated return of 14 percent is tantamount to winning the lottery, ’’ Brand wrote in her comments. “NJ Rate Counsel is concerned that this opportunity may be a key motivating factor behind the project.’’
In its comments, the NJ DEP cited concerns with the project’s impacts on high-quality streams in the state and lack of proof drilling would not impair them. The NJ DEP had some harsh words for FERC’s draft EIS by stating that “by no stretch of imagination can it be considered an ‘engineering and environmental anaylsis, ’ adding that portions of the report were “disingenuous’’ and “insulting.’’How much tips for dog grooming? What vitamins are in honey? what to helper t cells do Tips on how to hide heater? How to clear cloudy pool water fast? What vitamin are you lacking when tips of fingers crack? How to do rubber band magic tricks? What are your weaknesses and strengths? What does prodigy mean? Tricks to looking good during sex when you're heavy? What tips come with the cricut maker? Hark how the bells meaning? How did you do that tricks? What channel is the braves game on? How to charge nintendo switch controllers? How to grow garlic from a clove? What is the meaning of vicarius filii dei? What does nominal mean? What tricks are worth the most in project 8? why google helper opens so many processes in mac Exercise tips on how to lose belly fat? How long to cook pork shoulder in oven at 250? How to capture your cat tips? what activates the helper t cell What are your salary expectations? What is meaning of liberty? How long for food to digest? Places where harry houdini did his tricks? Tips on prospecting and recruiting people who speak other languages? What is osha? What is aspd? Who performed cheap tricks surrender on.a soundtrack? Tips on how to do a good interview? What are the first 10 amendments to the constitution called? How to check if your phone is tapped? How much does sns with tips cost? What does down syndrome mean? Why are the tips of my succulents drying up? How come my level 377 of candy crush saga only has 20 moves not 50 like the tips? What now rihanna song meaning? video downloader helper chrome where to save videos How to stay hydrated? What time does the dump close near me? how to use download helper with converters What does dap mean? How long to let baby cry it out? How to unblock chakras? How to quit vaping? What does a recession mean for me? Where to buy gorilla tips? Do you always hold cards in your left hand when doing card tricks? What is the true meaning of palm sunday? What is the meaning of clueless? How to get something notarized? How to talk to anyone: 92 little tricks for big success in relationships audio book torrent? What color is a mirror? What else is new meaning? What does metoprolol look like? What are the chances of getting into fri if im a tips scholar? Tips on how to dry up breast milk? What does analysis mean? How to insert a column in excel? How to check voicemail on android? What does perish judah mean? What county is brooklyn ny in? What does spider in dream meaning? How to make homemade meatballs? How to change default google account? how to play with wiiu usb helper How to read someone's text messages without their phone free? Tips on how to overcome depression? What color are the iphone 12? Study tips how to remember what you read? What does the name barbara mean? What does sync mean on my phone? What is the spiritual meaning of seeing a snake? How to make a beacon in minecraft? r how to make package that spit out helper window What to eat when wisdom teeth are removed? What does wps on my router mean? what is this box of hamburger helper doing in the spot of where this nestle quick How to hack facebook account? What does jovial mean? How to die in oregon? What does emmanuel mean? Where you at meaning? How to connect two monitors? How to search google like a pro_ 11 tricks you have to know? How to treat vaginitis? How to remove watermark from photo? What does recoupment mean? How to do card tricks book? What does kn mean? Where do you buy medical q-tips? How much does a waitress make an hour in massachusetts without tips? What does the bible say about weed? What are the factors of 6? How to clear search history on safari? How much stardust to trade shiny? How to unlock bike tricks in riders republic? Why did brian from new tricks leave? How to make time little alchemy? What are the after effects of a brain bleed? How to make hummus? What is flexeril? How to add apps to apple watch? How to become a judge? How to assemble a 5 by 5 tricks? how much should a stay at home momthers helper make What is the meaning of maddie? Site:pinterest.com/pin/ what is insulate britain meaning? How to do long multiplication? Why aren't hostess allowed to accept tips in georgia? What is devolution? Who lost finger tips guitar player? What does birdie mean in golf? How long in solitary confinement until mind starts playing tricks? What is mercury retrograde spiritual meaning 2022? Who does the skate boarding tricks in back to the future? spark framework handlebars where to register helper Tips on how to clean yourself with a broken rib? What does a dragon symbolize? What is the meaning of the easter egg? why are you interested in becoming a professional helper What seeing 911 meaning? How much do drip tips cost? What is the meaning of seeing ants in your house? What is a seven letter word meaning one fourth? How much does a pizza delivery driver make in tips? What does the prostate gland do? How to measure for blinds? What does shrooms look like? where do i put structured data markup helper How to cancel hellofresh subscription? What does cpu mean? What does 1111 mea? What is the meaning of balm? Any marketings tips when putting prices to services? How to get rid of ear wax without q tips? How to use oklahoma joe highland tips tricks? What salad to serve with steak tips? What are major tricks marks, minor tricks marks, and gridlines quizlet? What is body sculpting? How to know if you have diabetes? What is the beatitudes meaning? What is the meaning of following in facebook? What does endeavour mean? How to insert a row in excel? What are the tricks for my new puppy on disney channel? What is a name meaning warrior? Tips on how to swim faster? What does unicorn company meaning? How much do you make in tips at olive garden? What to look for in a fidget spinner for tricks? What does fraught mean? How to find the p value? Which of the following taxa belong at the tips of the branches on a phylogeny? How big is mars compared to earth? How to cancel facebook? What are pepperoncinis? What does sun moon and rising mean? Study tips + how to do better in school? How to unblock someone on iphone? What does it mean to have low blood pressure? How to help afghanistan? Why do peace lily leaf tips turn brown? What does the bible say about dating? What are the names of the 12 apostles? How does the agt clairvoyant do her tricks? How magic tricks revealed? How do they do those quick change tricks? When the forecast tricks you? How long does it take for lexapro to work? How to take blood pressure at home? How to clean a coffee pot? What is power bi? how much salt is in hamburger helper What is meaning of white roses? What does preserve mean? How to prevent glaucoma? What does a testicle look like outside of the sack? What does cdt mean? How to paint furniture? What does determine mean? where to put sumatr ahighlight helper Tips to show parents how to teach phonics at home? How to dummies books tips, good to know, caution? What does tht mean? how long does it take ups to pay driver helper bonus How to drain sinuses? node.js where to define global helper functions What is a manufactured home? How long to cook pork tenderloin in oven at 400? hypnospace outlaw how to delete professor helper how to adjust hellwig helper springs on motorhome What is the meaning of social vices? When applying for stamps do i add my tips? How long to cook a 20 pound turkey? How to train dog to do tricks? How to bcc in outlook? Tips on how to be successful on your pharmacy appes? What does stink mean? what is "apple icloud helper" 2018 What does a rainbow look like? What does great mean? How to drink more water? How to do tricks on a pogo stick? what is evernote helper and do i need it at startup Tips on how you get your cms 2014 review? How to beat wonder rabbit video game walkthrough cheats tips? How to cook a baked potato? How to do tricks in hill climb racing? How to stop masturbating? What is the meaning of shared services? what do t helper cells do with b cells How to draw a bear? Tips when learning to drive? What are nuclear deterrent forces? What is the meaning of hopeless? how much milk for hamburger helper how do i get rid of my inbox helper What is the meaning of a servant leader? What does the blue dot mean on android text? How to offload apps? What is 8mm in inches? What tips for uyuni? Rdr2 how to get robbery tips? How to become a librarian? Tips for getting into cardio as someone who hates cardio? How to make self rising flour? What are young turks? How to reverse insulin resistance? Who first said you can't teach an old dog new tricks? What does nsfl mean? what is adobe cef helper? What does reprisal mean? What does suv stand for? How to make ham glaze? wii u usb helper how to get the dlc What are persimmons? What is a term? How to check status of passport renewal? How to make sunny side up eggs? What does cis man mean? How many acvtive tricks van helsing? what do i need to do to be a welders helper what is the best way to make box hamburger helper cheeseburger macaroni taste better Pizza delivery how much do you make in tips? What does ambivert mean? How to eat ginger? What is the meaning of the word vanity? How to make seafood boil? Tips on how to make in gta v online? What is the meaning of great? How is it going to be meaning? Tips on how to care for a flag? What does blood mean gang? What is the meaning of bleeding heart flower? Episode where haley tricks everyone into thinking she is going into labor? Stride piano tricks how to play stride piano? What does category mean? Hqtrivia tips how to get free lives with fake account? What does anaphylaxis mean? What are the names of the great lakes? how to go from laborer and helper What is use case meaning? What god cannot do does not exist meaning? How to use dog nail clippers?